A tax notice should never be set aside. Notices from the Federal Board of Revenue and the Sindh Revenue Board carry short deadlines, and an unanswered notice becomes an assessment, a penalty, a frozen bank account or a notice to your employer. Most tax disputes are won or lost at the reply stage, on documents and on the law applied to them. This page explains the taxes that reach individuals and businesses in Karachi, the notices they send and what each means, how assessments and audits work, the appeal route, recovery and how to stop it, property transaction taxes, and the position of overseas Pakistanis. It is general information, not advice on a particular tax affair.
The law and the authorities
- Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, administered by the FBR's Inland Revenue: tax on income of individuals, associations and companies, withholding taxes, and the taxes collected on property and other transactions.
- Sales Tax Act, 1990: sales tax on goods, administered by the FBR.
- Sindh Sales Tax on Services Act, 2011: tax on services, administered by the Sindh Revenue Board (SRB).
- Federal Excise Act, 2005 and the Customs Act, 1969 for specific sectors.
Appeals go to the Commissioner Inland Revenue (Appeals) or the Appellate Tribunal Inland Revenue, then by reference to the Sindh High Court on questions of law. The statutes are on Pakistan Code; the FBR's portal is fbr.gov.pk and the SRB's srb.gos.pk.
The notices and what they mean
- Notice to file a return (section 114): the FBR believes you were required to file and did not. Filing late is usually better than ignoring it, and affects your status on the Active Taxpayers List.
- Unexplained income or assets (section 111): a bank deposit, property purchase, vehicle or foreign remittance that does not match your declared income. The reply must explain the source with documents; remittances through banking channels have a specific exemption that must be properly claimed.
- Amended assessment (section 122): a show-cause notice under section 122(9) proposing to amend your assessed income. This is the notice that leads to a tax demand, and the reply is the main opportunity to prevent it.
- Audit (section 177): selection for audit, with a request for books, bank statements and records. Audits end in an amended assessment unless the records support the return.
- Withholding default (sections 161 and 205): a business that failed to deduct or deposit tax on payments, with default surcharge.
- Recovery (sections 138 and 140): after an assessment, notices to pay, and attachment of bank accounts or recovery from persons who owe you money. An appeal with a stay application is the only reliable way to stop these.
- Sales tax and SRB notices: registration, input tax disallowance, short payment and audit, with similar structure and deadlines.
How assessments and audits work
Pakistan's system is self-assessment: the return you file is your assessment, and the FBR can amend it within the limitation period, generally five years, on definite information or audit. The officer must issue a show-cause notice stating the grounds, give a reasonable opportunity to reply and be heard, and pass a reasoned order; assessments made without these steps are set aside on appeal. The reply should address each ground with documents: bank statements, contracts, invoices, wealth statement reconciliation, remittance certificates and third-party confirmations. Adjournments are granted but not indefinitely, and an officer who receives no reply decides on the material before him.
Appeals
- Commissioner (Appeals) or Appellate Tribunal. Following the 2024 amendments, appeals go to the Commissioner Inland Revenue (Appeals) or, for larger demands, directly to the Appellate Tribunal Inland Revenue, within thirty days of the order. A stay of recovery is applied for with the appeal; without it recovery proceedings continue.
- Appellate Tribunal. Decides questions of fact and law; its decision is final on facts.
- Reference to the Sindh High Court on a question of law within the statutory period, and then the Supreme Court.
- Alternative Dispute Resolution under section 134A, through a committee, is available for suitable disputes and can be faster than the appellate chain.
Appeals succeed most often on procedure (no proper show-cause, no opportunity of hearing, time-barred amendment) and on documents that were not before the officer; both are easier to secure when the reply stage was handled properly.
Property transactions
Buying or selling property in Karachi attracts advance tax on both the seller (section 236C) and the buyer (section 236K) at rates that depend on filer status and value, collected at registration; capital gains tax on the seller under section 37 depending on the holding period; and, for the buyer, the obligation to explain the source of the purchase money if asked under section 111. Declaring the property in the wealth statement at the correct value avoids later notices. Rates change with each Finance Act, so they are confirmed for the specific transaction. See property and real estate.
Overseas Pakistanis
A person present in Pakistan for less than the days specified in the Ordinance in a tax year is a non-resident, taxed only on Pakistan-source income, such as rent, property gains and business income here, and not on foreign salary. Non-residents with Pakistan income should obtain an NTN, file a return and appear on the Active Taxpayers List to pay the lower filer rates on property transactions and bank profit; NICOP holders can register and file online from abroad. Foreign remittances through banking channels are not taxed as income and, properly documented, answer section 111 notices. See overseas Pakistanis.
Businesses: registration and withholding
Businesses register for income tax, sales tax on goods with the FBR where they supply taxable goods, and sales tax on services with the SRB where they provide services in Sindh; they must also withhold tax on salaries, rent, contracts and services and deposit it monthly, and file withholding statements. The most frequent business notices concern withholding defaults and sales tax input disallowance, both of which depend on records kept at the time. We set up compliance calendars and represent businesses in audits and appeals; see corporate and commercial.
Penalties and prosecution
Late filing, non-filing, concealment and withholding defaults attract penalties under section 182 and default surcharge, and serious concealment can be prosecuted. Voluntary correction before a notice, and candid disclosure in reply to one, reduce exposure; the Ordinance also provides for waiver of penalty in appropriate cases.
Documents to bring
- The notice, with its date and deadline
- Returns and wealth statements for the years concerned
- Bank statements, remittance certificates and the documents for any asset questioned
- Books of account, invoices and withholding records for businesses
- Earlier correspondence with the FBR or SRB
Timelines
Notice replies: usually fifteen to thirty days, extendable on request. Audit and amended assessment proceedings: months. Appeals: thirty days to file; Commissioner (Appeals) and Tribunal decisions within months to a year or more; High Court references longer. Stay applications are decided within weeks and are what protect bank accounts in the meantime.
Speak to a tax lawyer
Book a consultation as soon as a notice arrives and bring it with the returns and documents for the years concerned. The reply is where most tax disputes are decided.