A conviction is not the end of a criminal case. Appellate courts in Pakistan regularly set aside convictions for misreading of evidence, reduce sentences, and occasionally reverse acquittals. The two things that decide most appeals are the time limit, which is short, and the quality of the grounds drafted from a full reading of the trial record. This page explains where appeals go, the time limits, suspension of sentence pending appeal, appeals against acquittal, revisions, murder references and the Supreme Court. It is general information, not advice on a particular case.
Where the appeal goes
- Conviction by a Judicial Magistrate: appeal to the Court of Session under section 408 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898.
- Conviction by a Court of Session (Sessions Judge or Additional Sessions Judge): appeal to the High Court under section 410, in Karachi the Sindh High Court.
- Anti-Terrorism Court: appeal to a Division Bench of the High Court under the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997.
- High Court judgment: appeal or petition for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Pakistan under Article 185 of the Constitution.
- Acquittal: appeal by the State or the complainant under section 417, to the court that would have heard an appeal against conviction.
The Code is on Pakistan Code.
Time limits
The Limitation Act, 1908 sets the periods, which run from the date of the judgment:
- Seven days for an appeal against a sentence of death.
- Thirty days for an appeal to any court other than the High Court, for example from a Magistrate to the Sessions Court.
- Sixty days for an appeal to the High Court against conviction by a Sessions Court.
- Thirty days for a complainant's appeal against acquittal under section 417(2A).
- Thirty days for a petition for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in criminal matters.
The time taken to obtain a certified copy of the judgment is excluded, so apply for the copy on the day of judgment. Courts can condone delay for sufficient cause, but an explanation of every day of delay is required and condonation is never certain. A convict in jail may file a jail appeal through the superintendent, which the High Court treats with priority.
Suspension of sentence and bail pending appeal
Appeals in the Sindh High Court can take years to be heard. Under section 426 CrPC the appellate court may suspend the sentence and release the appellant on bail while the appeal is pending. Suspension is commonly granted where the sentence is short and would be served before the appeal is heard, where the appellant was on bail during the trial and did not misuse it, where there is a hardship such as serious illness, or where the appeal raises an obvious point. For long sentences the court looks for a prima facie case on the record. The application is filed with the appeal and is usually decided within weeks. Fines are stayed on deposit or security.
Appeals against acquittal
An acquitted person enjoys a double presumption of innocence, and appellate courts interfere with an acquittal only where the trial court's view is perverse, based on misreading or non-reading of evidence, or legally unsustainable; a different view that is also reasonable is not enough. The State appeals through the Prosecutor General; a complainant appeals under section 417(2A) within thirty days. Where the appeal succeeds the appellate court can convict and sentence, and it may also order a retrial.
Revisions
Where no appeal lies, or an interim order needs to be challenged, sections 435 to 439 CrPC allow the Sessions Court or the High Court to examine the record of a lower court for the correctness, legality or propriety of any finding, sentence or order. Revision is discretionary and is not a second appeal; it is used, for example, against orders framing a charge, refusing to summon a witness, or accepting or rejecting a cancellation report. The High Court can also enhance a sentence in revision after notice to the accused.
Murder references and death sentences
A death sentence passed by a Court of Session is not carried out until the High Court confirms it on a reference under section 374 CrPC, which is heard together with the convict's appeal by a Division Bench. The High Court re-examines the entire evidence and may confirm, commute to life imprisonment, alter the conviction, acquit or order a retrial. After the High Court, the convict may petition the Supreme Court and, finally, seek mercy from the President under Article 45 of the Constitution.
The Supreme Court
Under Article 185(2) an appeal lies as of right in a limited class of criminal cases, including where the High Court has reversed an acquittal and sentenced the accused to death or life imprisonment; in all other cases a petition for leave to appeal is filed under Article 185(3) within thirty days, and the Court grants leave only where a substantial question of law or a serious misreading of evidence is shown. Leave petitions are decided at a preliminary hearing; appeals after leave take longer.
What makes a strong appeal
- A complete reading of the trial record, including depositions, exhibits and the section 342 statement, not only the judgment.
- Contradictions between the FIR, the section 161 statements and the court depositions that the trial court overlooked or explained away.
- Legal defects: a charge not framed properly, a recovery without independent witnesses, an inadmissible confession, a sentence exceeding the court's powers, or a conviction on a section not charged.
- Medical or forensic evidence inconsistent with the ocular account.
- Reasoned alternative arguments on sentence where the conviction is likely to stand: first offender, age, the time already served, compromise with the victim's family.
How long appeals take in Karachi
Appeals in the Sessions Courts are usually decided within six months to a year. In the Sindh High Court, appeals against conviction commonly take two to four years to a final hearing, with jail appeals and appeals of persons in custody given priority; suspension of sentence is decided within weeks of filing. Supreme Court leave petitions are heard within months, appeals after leave take longer.
Documents to bring
- Certified copy of the judgment and the order on sentence, and the application receipt showing when the copy was requested
- The complete trial record if available: FIR, challan, depositions, exhibits, the section 342 statement
- Bail orders from the trial, and the surety documents
- Medical records or other material relevant to suspension of sentence
Speak to an appeals lawyer
If a judgment has been announced, the clock is running. Book a consultation and bring the judgment; we will advise on the forum, the time limit and whether suspension of sentence is realistic. We also act for complainants seeking to challenge an acquittal or an inadequate sentence.