When parents separate, the law of Pakistan asks one question before all others: what is in the welfare of the child? The traditional rules about which parent keeps a child of a given age are the starting point, not the answer. This page explains the difference between custody and guardianship, the mother's right of hizanat and when it gives way, what the Guardian Court in Karachi actually considers, visitation, taking a child abroad, and cross-border disputes. It is general information, not advice on a particular case.
The law
Custody and guardianship are governed by the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, read with Muslim personal law. Section 17 directs the court to be guided by the welfare of the minor, considering the child's age, sex and religion, the character and capacity of the proposed guardian, and the wishes of a child old enough to form an intelligent preference. Section 25 allows a guardian to apply for the return of a child removed from their custody, and section 26 prohibits taking a ward out of the court's jurisdiction without its permission. In Karachi these applications are heard by the Family Court of the district where the child ordinarily lives, sitting as the Guardian Judge, under the West Pakistan Family Courts Act, 1964. Both Acts are on Pakistan Code.
Custody and guardianship are different things
- Custody (hizanat) is the right to have the child live with you and care for them day to day.
- Guardianship (wilayat) concerns the child's person and property and the major decisions: schooling, medical treatment, travel, and the child's assets. Under Muslim personal law the father is the natural guardian, and remains so even while the mother has custody; he also remains responsible for the child's maintenance.
A mother with custody therefore still needs the father's, or the court's, consent for some decisions, and a father without custody retains duties as well as rights.
The mother's right of hizanat and its limits
Under the Hanafi rules applied to most Pakistani families, the mother is entitled to custody of a son until about the age of seven and of a daughter until puberty; Fiqh-e-Jafria families follow different ages. The right is not absolute. The classical grounds on which a mother may lose it include remarriage to a man not within the prohibited degrees to the child, neglect or immoral conduct, and moving the child far from the father so that he cannot exercise his rights. Pakistani courts, including the Supreme Court, have held repeatedly that these rules yield to the welfare of the particular child: a mother's remarriage, for example, is a factor to be weighed, not an automatic disqualification, and a father who has had no contact with a child for years will not be given custody merely because the child has turned seven.
What the court actually considers
- The age and sex of the child, and the child's own preference if old enough to express one; judges in Karachi commonly speak to children of school age privately in chambers.
- Who has been caring for the child and for how long; courts are slow to disturb a stable arrangement.
- Each parent's home, health, conduct and capacity to care, including the support of grandparents.
- Schooling, medical needs and keeping siblings together.
- Any history of violence, neglect, substance abuse or attempts to turn the child against the other parent.
- Financial capacity matters less than parents expect: the father's duty to maintain the child exists regardless of who has custody.
How a custody case runs in Karachi
- Application. A petition for custody (or for the return of a child under section 25, or for appointment as guardian under section 7) is filed in the Family Court of the district where the child ordinarily lives, with the child's B-form or birth certificate, the parents' CNICs and the nikahnama or divorce documents.
- Interim orders. At an early hearing the court can make interim arrangements: who the child stays with meanwhile, and a schedule for the other parent to meet the child, often at the court premises at first.
- Evidence. Each side files affidavits and is cross-examined; the court may call for a report on the child's school, home or health, and may interview the child.
- Final order. The court decides custody, guardianship where applied for, and a visitation schedule. Orders can later be varied if circumstances change, and can be appealed.
Interim visitation is usually fixed within weeks; a contested final decision commonly takes a year or more, longer with appeals. A written agreement between the parents, recorded as a court order, is the fastest and usually the best outcome for the child.
Visitation for the parent without custody
The parent who does not have custody is entitled to meet the child, and courts in Karachi fix schedules such as alternate weekends, a share of school holidays, Eid days and birthdays, and phone or video calls. Early in a dispute, meetings are often held at the court's family room; as trust builds they move to the parent's home and overnight stays. A parent who obstructs a visitation order can be brought back before the court, and persistent obstruction counts against that parent on the question of custody itself.
Taking a child abroad
Section 26 of the Act prohibits removing a child from the court's jurisdiction while proceedings are pending without the court's leave, and a child's passport generally requires the father's consent as guardian. A parent who fears removal can ask the court for a restraint order and for the child's name to be placed on the exit control list through the proper channel. A parent who wants to relocate with the child, or to take the child on a visit abroad, should apply for permission with a proposed schedule for contact with the other parent and an undertaking to return; courts grant such permission where the welfare of the child supports it.
Cross-border custody disputes
Pakistan is not a party to the 1980 Hague Convention on child abduction, so a foreign court's custody order is not automatically enforced here; Pakistani courts decide on the welfare of the child, giving weight to the foreign order and to the child's settled life. The UK–Pakistan Judicial Protocol of 2003 guides courts in cases between the two countries, favouring the return of a child to the country of habitual residence. A parent abroad can pursue a case in Karachi through a power of attorney, and courts increasingly allow their evidence by video link. See overseas Pakistanis.
Documents to keep ready
- Child's B-form or birth certificate, and school records
- Parents' CNICs or NICOPs, nikahnama, and any talaq or khula documents
- Medical records if relevant, and evidence of who has been caring for the child
- Messages or orders relevant to contact, obstruction or any risk to the child
Speak to a custody lawyer
Custody cases go better when the first hearing is prepared properly and the proposals put to the court are realistic for the child. Request a confidential consultation with our family law team, in Karachi or by video call if you live abroad. Our guide answers the questions mothers ask most often.