The 27th Amendment to the Constitution, passed in November 2025, created the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) and moved constitutional work away from the Supreme Court. A year on, the two courts are still settling the boundary between them. On 2 November 2026, Daily Pakistan reported an FCC decision explaining that a party challenging a High Court ruling under Article 175F(1)(c) must first obtain leave to appeal from the FCC, and that leave "is not automatically granted". This note explains, in general terms, where an appeal now goes.
Constitutional petitions: the Federal Constitutional Court
Under Article 175F(1)(c), an appeal against a judgment or order of a High Court made under Article 199, the writ jurisdiction, lies to the FCC only if the FCC grants leave. According to the report, the FCC asks at the leave stage whether the case raises a legal question that needs its intervention, or whether intervention is needed to prevent a miscarriage of justice. Only after leave is granted does the matter proceed as a regular appeal. The FCC can also hear appeals where an Act of Parliament provides for it, or where the High Court certifies that the case involves a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution.
The Supreme Court's former original jurisdiction under Article 184(3), often used for public interest cases, no longer applies, because the amendment omitted Article 184. Matters pending before the Supreme Court that fell within the FCC's new jurisdiction were transferred to the FCC.
Rent and family cases: still the Supreme Court
The proviso to Article 175F(1)(c) excludes writ judgments in rent and family cases, other than guardianship and matters fixed by law, from the FCC's appellate jurisdiction. In January 2026, The Nation reported that the Supreme Court held these cases remain within its own appellate jurisdiction under Article 185(3), subject to leave. A tenant, landlord or spouse who loses a writ petition in the High Court in such a case therefore goes to the Supreme Court, not the FCC.
Ordinary civil and criminal appeals: the Supreme Court
Regular civil and criminal appeals from High Court judgments, including the appeals as of right listed in Article 185(2), remain with the Supreme Court. In May 2026, Daily Times reported that the Chief Justice of Pakistan described the two as coordinate courts with separate jurisdictions, neither of which hears appeals from the other. Our page on criminal appeals explains that route.
The courts are still working out the details
The relationship is not fully settled. In early November 2026, the FCC reportedly held that the legal observations in its judgments bind all courts, including the Supreme Court, and a Supreme Court bench questioned that view. Cases that mix writ and non-writ questions, or criminal matters decided under Article 199, can raise questions about the right forum.
What this means for you
- Do not assume that the old route still applies. Check which court has jurisdiction before you file anything.
- Time limits for a petition for leave are short, and time spent in the wrong court may not be recovered. Get the certified copy of the High Court judgment at once.
- The leave petition must show why the case needs the higher court's attention. It is not simply a rehearing of the High Court case.
Our page on constitutional petitions explains writ petitions in the Sindh High Court and what follows. If the High Court has decided against you, request a consultation early so that the next step is taken within time.